Recession and Outsourcing - Moral Dilemma

A recession is defined as a decline in a country'swhatever available resources they have. And they
Gross Domestic product (GDP) or negativewould look at outsourcing option as one which
growth for two or more successive quarters of acould lead to sustained profitability because of the
year.lower costs involved and 24/7 availability of the
Recession is caused by any one or combination ofoutsourcing vendor.
the following factors:But at the other spectrum of the debate is rising
1. Currency Crisis:- This happens when the valueunemployment. In Nov'08, unemployment in US
of a currency changes quickly, undermining itswas at 4.9% with economists predicting a further
ability to serve as a medium of exchange.rise to about 6% to 7%. In fact, in October,
2. Inflation;- It is the result of a rise in the general2008, the service sector of US shed about
level of prices of goods and services in an240,000 jobs. And that's a huge number we are
economy over a period of time.looking at!
3. National Debt:- Recession follows when aAnd this has stirred the conscience of many a
sovereign government is unable to pay offbusinesses. The thinking is: when my own
national debt.countrymen are losing jobs, why do I ship jobs to
4. Speculation & economic bubbles:-other countries? I could very well help few of my
Speculation causes prices to deviate from theircountrymen offering jobs at reduced costs.
intrinsic value. Recession follows when such hypedWhile this line of thinking is certainly appreciable, it
prices crash.is pertinent to note that outsourcing is not a tool
5. War:- When two or more nations are at warto reduce job opportunity in a country.
over a considerable period of time, it can proveOutsourcing should be used as a strategic tool for
to be a drain on the economy and can result ina business to grow and not look at it as a mere
recessionary trends.tool for cost control.
6. Under consumption:- When there is underHere is a small illustration of what it means:
consumption it leads to a situation whereSuppose a businessman A has an in-house
stagnation will set in as production will be stopped,accountant to record his daily transactions and
resulting in recession.prepare the monthly Income & Expense
7. Over production:- If there is over production onStatement for helping the businessman to take
a large scale, it would lead to the reduction instrategic decision about his business. On an
value of the produced goods, thereby leading toaverage, the hourly rate for an accountant (with
lower prices and unsold stock.less than 1 year of experience) is $14.14. The
The current recession seems to be the fallout ofmonthly fixed cost assuming a 40 hours week
bursting of Economic (read Housing) bubble andwould be $2,262. And this is only for accounting.
overproduction (read over availability of mortgageThe businessman has to again shell out $300
credit).upwards for preparing his business's tax return
The real estate prices had been growing tofrom a CPA.
astronomical figures due to hyped demand. ThisOn the contrary, if businessman A decides to
hype in demand had been caused byoutsource his entire accounting function to an
over-availability of easy credit. When there wasoutsourcing vendor in India, at the lowest quote
snap in one of them, the entire bubble burst. Addavailable for outsourcing accounting, he would be
to that, the continued rise in oil & steel pricescharged $1,280 per month for all services including
and the stage was set for recession in US. Thethe tax return preparation. Add to this, the
involvement of big players the world overbenefit of getting highly professional reports on
resulted in this enormous recession in the entirethe current state of the business which would be
world.far better than reports generated by an
The recession in US has been confirmed by aaccountant with less than a year's experience.
negative growth of GDP. In fact the GDP in USSo, cost wise, it makes sense to outsource
has shrunk 0.5%, the most since 2001 (when theaccounting to outsourcing vendor in India. But
last recession took place).doesn't that mean making one person jobless?
What has been the fallout of this recession in US?Not necessarily. The person's time can be split
Bankruptciesinto: time to interact with the outsourcing vendor
Squeeze in credit availability from banksfor reports etc. and time for the core area of the
Foreclosuresbusiness. This would have two pronged effect on
Reduced salesthe person and the business:a) The person would
Stock Market crashbe able to generate additional direct revenue for
Rise in Unemploymentthe business and also learn a lot from associating
So, how does recession impact outsourcing?with professionals at outsourcing vendor's office.b)
As it has with all other forms of businesses,The business gets additional revenue while cutting
recession also has a huge impact on outsourcing.down the overhead.
And the impact on outsourcing can be as variedThus by associating with an outsourcing vendor in
as the two poles!India, you can do business without hurting your
Since in recessionary times, there is severe creditconscience!
& fund crunch, businesses will like to optimize