Knol - Wikipedia's Rival

There's a new kid on the online block named KnolInternet and its various content.
and even this early in the development stage,Manber also stated that another important goal of
some people are already predicting that it couldKnol was to cover a wide range of topics, from
bring about yet another significant change to thethe various sciences to health concerns to history.
way we share information on the Internet.Eventually they hope to have Knol become the
Knol is a new Web service being developed byfirst stop for research on any topic. Today it is
Google that is meant to serve as a virtualWikipedia that provides that function and its web
storehouse of knowledge on the Internet. Withpages show up at the top of the results page of
content being contributed by various experts onGoogle and many other search engines more
different topics, it will behave much in the sameoften than not.
way that Wikipedia does currently. In fact manySome in the industry have suggested that this
industry experts have made the suggestion thatlatest move of Google is driven by the
Knol is set to become a direct competitor tounprecedented growth of web sites that combine
Wikipedia and other similar types of web sites.knowledge resources such as Wikepedia, and that
Google is of course the go to web site as far asGoogle feels the need to have a strong presence
search engines go, being the most popular searchin that particular area.
engine web site today by far. If Knol is asWikipedia is by no means the only web site that
successful in drawing a widespread following asoffers that type of service. Many other
the developers hope, it could bring about thecompanies have taken slightly different
Google's transition from a search engine into aapproaches in functioning as knowledge
company that creates and publishes Web content.repositories on various topics on the Internet.
Some industry observers warn that one problemThese services include Squidoo, Yahoo Answers,
that could potentially arise is that Google'sand Mahalo.
objectivity in presenting search results could beIn spite of the widespread popularity of these
compromised.services-as well as the existence of many free
Knol-the name of which is derived from the wordtools that allow experts and regular people the
"knowledge"-is being developed to allow people tomeans by which they can share their knowledge
create Web pages on virtually any topic. Whenonline-Manber said that Google feels that it is still
completed, it will include several features that willnot easy enough for the average user to do
allow its users the ability to perform a number ofthose things.
tasks, such as submitting comments, ratingInterestingly, considering all the hype and
individual web pages and suggesting changes.excitement that is currently surrounding the news
We mentioned earlier in this article that Knol hasof Knol's existence, Google has refrained from
been compared to Wikipedia by many industrydiscussing the project any further than these initial
analysts. While there are in fact many similaritiesdetails, and have even said that it is still an
between the two web services, the mainexperimental project at this time. This means that
difference is that Wikipedia allows virtually anyonejust like many other Google tests that never saw
to edit an entry while Knol only allows the authorthe light of day, Knol could end up never even
of each particular "knol,"-which is what thebeing released publicly at all.
individual pages in the service will be called-to doAs for Wikipedia, site founder Jimmy Wales has
so. This means that the same topics could havedownplayed his site's comparison with Knol, saying
many different authors with sometimesthat while Wikipedia's goal is utmost objectivity in
contrasting-or even competing-points of view.its content, with each individual article being the
Google has stated that the main thrust of thesum total of the collective knowledge of its
Knol project was to focus attention on authorsvarious authors, Knol's model will likely result in
who have sufficient expertise on particular topics.highly opinionated and possible even contradictory
As vice president for engineering at Google Udiarticles on even the simplest of topics.
Manber wrote in the Google corporate blogAnother important distinction is that Wikipedia is a
recently, the Internet has evolved largely withoutstrictly non profit web site that does not carry
the benefit of a standardized means to highlightany type of advertising, while Knol is a decidedly
the author's name on each web article. He goesmore commercial venture, with its content
on to say that the company believes thatauthors earning revenue from any Google ads on
knowing who wrote a particular web article whattheir site.
will considerably aid users make better use of the